Hydrogen for European industry: from technical readiness to market readiness
HyInHeat is researching the use of hydrogen in the aluminium and steel industries
Hydrogen could play a key role in the decarbonisation of energy-intensive industries, but its widespread use depends on more than just technological readiness. Francesca Cavezza from the European Aluminium Association discusses the key political, economic and infrastructural challenges shaping the uptake of hydrogen in European industry.
Has your perspective on hydrogen changed whilst working on this project?
Yes, in a certain way. At the start, I thought the main issue was the technology: does the equipment work well enough? It does. What has changed for me is that I now believe the real problem is economic, not technical. We saw that more than a billion euros were allocated at the hydrogen bank auction, but a large proportion of that capacity was later returned because the companies couldn’t find buyers willing to pay the price offered. That showed me that the question is not ‘Can we build this?’, but ‘Can we guarantee that someone will pay for it for fifteen years?’ This is more of a financing problem than a technical one, and it must be resolved as such.
If you had to set one priority for European decision-makers, what would it be?
Support hydrogen over the long term, not in short bursts. The industry has told us directly: they do not need another one-off grant scheme. They need stable support for operating costs over many years in order to be able to plan a long-term investment. The actual level of support makes it very difficult for a steel or aluminium company to commit to a furnace retrofit costing billions of euros. If I could change one thing, it would be this: make the support predictable and long-term, linked to real demand, not a one-off payment.
What surprised you most when analysing the current political situation?
It is important for both sectors, but for different reasons. In the steel industry, hydrogen can directly replace the coal used in the core chemical reaction, thereby eliminating emissions directly at source. That is why it is receiving so much attention there. In the aluminium sector, hydrogen mainly comes into play as a substitute for natural gas-based processes, either where electrification is not a realistic option, or where geography makes it a more sensible choice. There is also a broader value beyond direct use: hydrogen can store energy from renewable sources, enabling it to transport this clean electricity into industrial processes, even if it is not consumed directly as electricity.
Are European industries ready to adopt hydrogen today?
Technically speaking, they are closer than most people realise: the furnaces, burners and monitoring systems already exist and are being tested. Economically speaking, however, they are not yet ready. In our survey, all companies cited cost as the biggest hurdle, and it is by no means a small gap: production using hydrogen is still much more expensive than the fossil-fuel-based process it would replace. Added to this is the fact that the infrastructure is patchy: some regions have access to pipelines, others do not, and the companies supplying the equipment have told us that production capacity in Europe is not yet sufficient. So the honest answer is: the technology can be tested today, but the economics and supply chains are not yet ready for full-scale deployment.
What role do research and innovation projects such as HyInHeat play in this transition?
They solve a problem that policy and the market alone cannot easily resolve: nobody wants to be the first to take on the full risk. In our survey, technology providers said that these projects are valuable because they share technical knowledge that would otherwise remain confined within a single company, and because they offer a safer space to test how hydrogen systems work on a real industrial scale before a company risks an entire production line on them. They also build connections between researchers, equipment suppliers and industrial customers, which can later develop into real projects. What they cannot do – and nobody in the survey claimed they could – is resolve the underlying cost and infrastructure issues themselves. That remains the task of policymakers.
If you could leave readers with one message from this work, what would it be?
Don’t treat ‘hydrogen for industry’ as a single narrative. Steel and aluminium are really taking different paths, and policymakers should stop treating them the same. Furthermore, if I had to choose one thought to leave readers with: the question is no longer whether hydrogen works for heavy industry. The real question now is whether Europe’s financial and regulatory support will remain stable and predictable for long enough to allow companies to actually invest their money.
Source: HyInHeat
European research project HyInHeat
In brief: Hydrogen research for the metals industries.
- The HyInHeat consortium is a diverse and collaborative network of 30 partners from 12 European countries.
- The common goal is to develop and demonstrate innovative, hydrogen-based heating technologies for energy-intensive industries
- The project partners possess expertise in various areas of industrial heating, including combustion, furnaces, sensors, safety and sustainability. The consortium comprises leading research institutes, technology and plant engineering firms, as well as industrial companies from the aluminium and steel sectors.
- Another key focus is on the commercialisation and dissemination of the technologies.